
For the past 5 months I have been working on a short film for the PHMA on a film called Louie Logo in “Helmet Safety” about the benefits of using a helmet when you skate, ride a bike, horse, play soccer or use a scooter.
It’s been an awesome experience and I am very proud of the way it came out. My contact at PHMA; Dean Fisher has been the best client I have ever worked with and after this has taken 6 months to do, we have gotten to know each other a bit as well which is nice.
But it has also been an arduous process and I have learned a lot by doing it, mostly by doing things the wrong way 12 times and banging my head against the wall repeatedly (which by the way is a bad thing).
I am in the final stages of putting the film on DVD and let me tell you doing that very thing has not been a picnic.
Entirely animated in Flash, Louie Logo is the first project of this magnitude I have taken on. I have seen many other shows on TV work with Flash and I figured I could do the same.
Most of the shows that are done in Flash are exported to a Quicktime movie or a series of stills and then brought into an Avid system or Final Cut Pro for mixing and editing.
I’m not quite sure exactly how they do it because I have had nothing but trouble trying to accomplish it. I did succeed at the end but you’ll have to read the whole story to see how I did it. ;-)
I tried so many different ways I am literally spewing over with file versions and codecs and exports and details.
I have finally realized after all this that Flash sucks for this and yet it is a vaible tool for production.
The basic process is to export a swf from Flash in a v5 Flash Player format and then import that into After Effects. Then export that file out to a Quicktime or an AVI.
All this works without a flaw. It looks beautiful. Crystal clear and smooth motions.
That’s where the honeymoon ends.
After Effects does not export sound as far as I can tell (if it does, I have yet to find out how), so after exporting the video out of AE, I bring the file into Premiere and add sound efx and the sound track by exporting the dialog I animated to out of Flash and importing that back into Premiere.
Still with me? ;-)
So once I import the sound into Premiere it seems fine at first until I want to edit some of the video footage. In my film there is a small clip of live action video which will not export from Flash because Flash Player 5′s format does not support video so the vid drops out on export and I am left witha big white space in the film.
No problem right? Just splice the video footage in and we should be set.
But no!
The minute that I use the splice tool to cut a point to edit, the 2nd half of the film suddenly changes. Yes, changes. The image switches to the beginning of the film! Amazing! Sometimes (as I have done this more than once) it just goes black instead of swtiching to the beginning of the film. Amazing!
So I can not edit the film in Premiere and Vegas won’t even see the file at all!
So I go back to Flash and try to make it work there by exporting the sound which has 12 layers now in Premier and importing that into Flash. Trouble is slowly over time it drifts out of sync and by the end of the 7 minutes it is like a full second off!
Tough stuff.
I would pull my hair out at this point but I don’t have much so I can’t!
Next I decide I will export a still frame sequence from Flash, import it into Premiere and I should be good to go.
Nope. Don’t work. Every time I try that Premiere will only let me import 100 frames at a time and I have over 11,000!
Nevertheless I try importing it bit by bit but after a while Premiere craps out on me and quits!
At this point I scream.
It has been very difficult to get everything working.
I did figure it out though.
I imported the Quicktime file into Premiere, added another layer on top of that for the live action footage without splicing it into the same layer and that seems to work so I solved the edit problem. That still leaves the sync problem.
Digital video is 30 fps (frames per second) but it renders at 29.97. Don’t ask me why.
Well when that happesn the sound that the file pulls from is still at 30 fps and it slowy rifts off over time.
The solution?
Compress the sound with something like Soug Frge to 99.99 and suddenly it syncs up! Imagine that!
Can you say NIGHTMARE!?!?
So now we’ve got the file in Premiere, with sound that syncs and it looks good.
Yay!
But wait! We’re not done!
The biggest problem is that when I render the file out compressed, it is pixelated and looks essentially like crap. When I export it out uncompressed it balloons up to around 8 gigabytes!
Shoot me now.
The client had asked me to deliver the film on CD so he can dupe it and give it to his partners whcih I can totally dig but the file at 8 gb is not going onto a 650 mb disk. I can;t burn it to DVD because he can’t duplicate that. Besides 8 gb won’t fit on a DVD either.
Sigh…
Well I can burn it to a dual layer DVD but they aren’t as easy to mass duplicate and I don’t have one anyway…
What do I do?
The Windows version of Flash will export a Quicktime but it’s not “really” a Quicktime file, but actually just a swf that can play in Quicktime’s Player.
That means no editing program will see the file.
Well I found out that apparently the Mac although as far as I am concerned is a bit like a Fisher-Price toy seems to have one great thing going for it. Quicktime with the Mac version of Flash can actually export a beautiful Quicktime movie with soud right out of Flash. And it’s hugely compressed too! Imagine that?!?!?!
So although I figured out a way to get the file out of Flash and make it onto a DVD which the client is kind enough to accept, but it was a very frustrating process.
So I bought a Mac.
I need to author a DVD now to make it mass produceable.
The solution?
Final Cut Pro and iDVD.
But I have to break down and actually buy a Mac to use those programs. Bought one last night in fact.
I have not had a Mac for about 8 years now and here I am slinking back in again.
Will the madness never end!?!?
Well anyway, if you’re actually still reading this to the end, thank you.
You are braver than I…
Oh and stay away from Flash! It is evil to it’s core!
;-)